CDLWire
From the November 16, 2026 edition (Latest news)
Regulations

The 121 revoked ELDs came from just 84 providers — and more than half of this year's revocations trace to repeat names

Commercial Carrier Journal's count of the Nov. 12 list finds 65 of the 121 devices spread across 26 providers with two or more devices revoked, E-Log Plus alone losing five — and the American Trucking Associations expects to unveil a third-party certification roadmap this week.

Summarized from Commercial Carrier Journal.

Illustration of a truck driver in a semi truck cab looking at a tablet showing multiple electronic logging device apps, with an inspection station ahead

On the list of electronic logging devices revoked by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration on Thursday, you will find 121 device names but not 121 different providers, according to Commercial Carrier Journal on Nov. 15 — a provider-level count of last week's record revocation that reframes what FMCSA removed, and what removing it can fix.

Sixty-five of the removed devices were distributed across 26 providers with two or more devices, leaving just 84 unique providers for the 121 devices, CCJ's analysis found. E-Log Plus had five devices revoked, three providers had four devices removed, four providers had three removed, and 18 providers each had two devices pulled from the registry. Out of the 816 currently registered ELDs, 46.69% (381 devices) are from a company name with two or more devices listed, belonging to 121 unique companies, CCJ found. And the year's full record is more concentrated still: FMCSA has dropped 221 ELDs from its registered list this year, though some have been reinstated after regaining compliance. That broader 2026 list includes 88 company names with multiple devices listed, with five companies each accounting for 10 or more. Of the ELDs revoked or self-revoked in 2026, 125 devices (56.56%) were made by companies that had two or more devices revoked during 2026, and 193 (87.33%) of the 221 were manufactured or registered by companies that had two or more total devices on the registry across its history.

The reason concentration matters is that the devices in a family are not really separate products. "We've identified entire families of ELDs operating on the same underlying code," National Motor Freight Traffic Association Chief Operating Officer Joe Ohr told CCJ. "When one device is revoked, another can simply take its place. Revoking individual devices isn't enough. We need to address the entire family." The practice is commonly referred to as white labeling, "and it leads to real enforcement challenges," said Brandon Wiseman, founder and president of Trucksafe Consulting. In many cases, Ohr added, the backend database is the same, so it is easy for the driver to switch between the two.

Underneath the families sits the registry's front door. FMCSA does not perform pre-market testing, third-party lab evaluations, or upfront document vetting. Self-certifying and registering an ELD is an online administrative process that can be done in just a few hours of data entry, and the United States stands alone in how it validates the technology that monitors truckers' drive time. Canada mandates third-party certification for its devices, and the European Union uses digital tachographs with designated national type-approval authorities and accredited laboratories. "Self-certification is a rubber stamp based on a pinky promise. We have over 1,000 ELDs verified while Canada is less than 50," Ohr said. "We have seen missing and blank info on the certification portal. This allows bad actors to certify unlimited ELDs under different names, and if one is shut down, the driver just loads the new Android app."

That front door is where the next move lands. The American Trucking Associations expects to unveil this week a comprehensive roadmap to strengthen the ELD certification process by introducing third-party certification "and closing the front door on fraudsters seeking to exploit weaknesses in the system." Wiseman noted it is past time for FMCSA to transition away from self-certification, but cautioned that the next steps should be planned carefully with public input. "Third-party certification presents its own challenges," he said, "and Canada has experienced them, including a long and sometimes expensive certification process that leads to fewer available devices and can result in increased costs to consumers. We have to balance those things in developing a plan." To combat white labeling in the meantime, Ohr suggested FMCSA require companies to disclose at registration if a device is part of a family, require the Android Package Kit, and run code comparisons — a process NMFTA used to analyze close to 80% of devices, shared with FMCSA, and volunteered to train the agency on.

Both men also drew the line carriers need to hear: multiple devices are not an automatic red flag. "There are some legitimate providers on the list that have multiple devices," Wiseman said. Trimble, for example, has eight listed, although six are tied to PeopleNet, which Trimble sold to Platform Science last year, and the other two are versions 1.0 and 2.0 of its Oil and Gas ELD. "While there are circumstances where it makes sense," Ohr said, "it still needs to be researched and buyers need to be informed." Wiseman's advice was the practical version: do your homework before settling on a device, talk with other customers, and demo the device.

For a carrier replacing a revoked device this month — CDLWire's Nov. 13 coverage of the revocation itself, including the conflicting Nov. 24 and 60-day deadlines in FMCSA's own documents, stands as published — CCJ's count adds one check to the shopping list. The question is no longer only whether the replacement's exact name, model and identifier are on the registered list today. It is who else sells the same underlying product, and how many of that provider's other devices have already been revoked this year. A replacement drawn from a family with a revocation history can be revoked again by the same pattern, and 125 of this year's 221 removals say that pattern is the unit FMCSA is really fighting.

Source: Commercial Carrier Journal
Image: Illustration: AI-generated by CDLWire

Sources

Commercial Carrier Journal

Comments

Loading comments…

Leave a comment

No account or email needed. Every comment is reviewed by a person before it appears.

CDLWire by email

The trucking news briefing, in your inbox. You're on the list the moment you sign up — no confirmation email, no waiting. Unsubscribe any time.